The leftist journalist John L.
Spivak, in commenting upon the alleged conspiracy by industrialists to stage a
military-backed coup in 1933—the so-called “Business Plot”—with the intent of
“forcing” FDR to accept being a figurehead president, noted that
The takeover plot failed because though those involved had astonishing
talents for making breathtaking millions of dollars, they lacked an elementary
understanding of people and the moral forces that activate them. In a
money-standard civilization such as ours, the universal regard for anyone who
is rich tends to persuade some millionaires that they are knowledgeable in
fields other than the making of money. The conspirators went about the plot as
if they were hiring an office manager; all they needed was to send a messenger
to the man they had selected.
The
“office manager” the industrialists—the same kind of people that FDR in his
famous 1936 Madison Square Garden speech proclaimed that he “welcomed their
hatred”—hoped to recruit was Maj. Gen. Smedley Butler, who had supported the "Bonus Army" protesters. However, they seemed to have missed what Butler said in a speech prior to his being approached for this mission:
I suspected I was just part of a racket at
the time. Now I am sure of it. Like all the members of the military profession,
I never had a thought of my own until I left the service. My mental faculties
remained in suspended animation while I obeyed the orders of higher-ups. This
is typical with everyone in the military service. I helped make Mexico,
especially Tampico, safe for American oil interests in 1914. I helped make
Haiti and Cuba a decent place for the National City Bank boys to collect
revenues in. I helped in the raping of half a dozen Central American republics
for the benefit of Wall Street…I helped purify Nicaragua for the international
banking house of Brown Brothers in 1909-1912. I brought light to the Dominican
Republic for American sugar interests in 1916. In China I helped to see to it
that Standard Oil went its way unmolested.
In
testimony before Congress, Butler claimed that a Gerald MacGuire repeatedly contacted
him about supplying him with 500,000 armed men and financial support if he led
a fascist takeover of the government. At the time, near everyone regarded the
whole thing as a complete hoax, although given Butler’s impeccable reputation,
it was believed that MacGuire was engaged in “exploring” the possibility of a
coup on behalf of wealthy backers for whom the New Deal was anathema, and who would
all deny any knowledge of the alleged plot. But if indeed Butler was approached
to lead a fascist-style takeover of the government (the “pretext” being that
FDR was in “ill health”), the alleged plotters seriously misread their man, for
Butler was well known for his support of FDR and antipathy toward unrestrained
capitalism.
As Spivak noted, the rich seem to
think that since they are good at making money, that makes them “qualified” in
other fields of endeavor, as if they can “buy” a PH.D without actually having
to take a single class or read a single book on any subject that requires a
modicum of intellect or critical thinking. We have heard Donald Trump
repeatedly claim his “genius” in a variety of fields in which he offered
crackpot ideas, and his belief he was “smarter” than all the generals in the
military. If we need any more proof—or rather, just
more to put on top of the Mount Everest-sized pile—that Trump’s presidency has been nothing more than
a massive ego-trip bereft of any semblance of intellectual curiosity (other
than, say, drinking deadly chemicals to “kill”
the COVID-19). Nor does Trump (save for his most fanatical base) possess
that “elementary understanding of people and the moral forces that
activate them,” which was borne out by the fact that even in states with
Republican-controlled legislatures or governors that Joe Biden won, the
governors and election officials refused
to heed Trump’s pressure to overturn the election on ethical and legal
grounds.
But
that hasn’t stopped Trump from keeping his focus on riling up his personal
militias on election fraud conspiracies while the world around him is falling
apart. While once more Trump is trying to convince the U.S. Supreme Court to
give him just one court “victory”—again targeting a state (Pennsylvania) with a
Republican-dominated legislature that approved expanded mail-in voting—his
insistence that cyber security, especially that targeting Russian hacking
efforts, is just another thing that makes him look “bad.” His insistence on
believing Vladimir Putin’s lies has opened this country to massive security
breaches as we see now with the SolarWinds episode. Trump did not want to hear
anything about Russian hacking, and this refusal gave Russian hackers a
“window” to operate freely, because they knew that cyber security experts were
afraid for their jobs if they brought the subject up. This latest hacking
allegedly began this past March, which gave the hackers (likely Russian
intelligence agents), plenty of time to do a great deal of damage. Of course
the Russians are going to deny it; only a fool like Trump actually believes
such denials.
Of
course the pandemic continues to rage all over the world, and in this country
we find that Texas and Florida deliberately reduced testing and “reevaluated”
what qualified as a COVID-19 death, while delaying reporting before the
election in an obvious effort to effect the vote. Trump’s own attitude toward
the virus seems to be “If you don’t talk about it, it isn’t real,” and that
goes for testing too. Of course with millions of Trump supporters who don’t
believe the virus is “real,” it doesn’t really matter if Trump is only
concerned about his political life and not that of people who haven’t stopped
breathing yet.
For
Trump’s “army,” the battle continues for what can only be described as a
fascist overthrow of democracy. According to Politico, Trump’s most numb-nut
supporters—including Sidney Powell and Michael Flynn—have called on Trump to
impose martial law via the Insurrection Act to undo the election:
Nonetheless, in the minds of some authoritarian-leaning and
conspiracy-minded Trump supporters, the Insurrection Act has become a needed
step to prevent President-elect Joe Biden from assuming the presidency. Their
evidence-deficient reasoning: Democrats illegally rigged the election and are
attempting a coup, and Trump must send in the troops to undo this conspiracy.
The conviction shows how hard-edged MAGA ideology has become in the wake of
Trump’s election loss. While scattered theories about a “deep state” arrayed
against Trump have long circulated in MAGA circles, calls for troops to stop a
democratically elected president from taking office have taken those ideas to a
more conspiratorial and militaristic level. It also displays the exalted level
to which Trump has been elevated among his most zealous fans as his departure
looms.
Let’s recall that the 1933 “Business Plot” was
to operate along similar lines, albeit under less “secrecy.” Today we have an
anti-democratic conspiracy being led by a “businessman” who has lived his
entire life ruled by his own laws and cannot function by compromise, or accept
“losing.” Trump has deliberately sought to inflame his base with evidence-free
claims of fraud without a single thought about the danger of doing so. He has
been less than subtle about his supporters taking to the streets to overturn the
election on his behalf. His supporters have in fact taken to the streets,
sometimes violently and often armed to “protest” the election result. Given
Trump’s abnormal behavior that is being fed by many far-right Republicans and media,
it is a very real danger that if an “army” of Trump supporters did march on
Washington DC to prevent Biden from taking office, Trump would do nothing to
stop it. If Trump actually called on the Army itself to perform that action in
order to prevent an “illegal” president from taking office, it would pose the
most serious crisis in this country’s history since the Civil War.
Trump is actually “keen” on the idea, but he
twists it by claiming it is to send out the Army to quell an “insurrection” by
anti-Trump protesters, if he actually refuses to leave office because of what
he would call “proven fraud,” as he suggested to Fox News’ Jeanine Pirro. The effort to concoct such “proven fraud”
continues apace, as the New York Times
reported that on Friday there was a “raucous” meeting that included Sidney
Powell in which Trump proposed that Powell be appointed “special prosecutor” to
investigate election fraud. Most Trump advisors opposed such a move,
including Rudy Giuliani, because of the likelihood that such an investigation
by Powell would only provide more embarrassment for the regime, given her incompetence
and habit of promoting the most bizarre conspiracies, and “witnesses” and
“experts” who turn out to be complete fakers themselves.
Meanwhile, a far-right group called True the
Vote is attempting to “preemptively” disenfranchise 360,000 voters in Georgia
prior to the runoff elections to determine control of the U.S. Senate. Some
counties have taken their own steps to suppress the vote by reducing the number
of early voting stations, which has led to the issuing of complaints to
election officials. It is worth noting
that in this country there are 240 million people who are legally qualified to
vote, with the number who did not vote in 2020 roughly equal to the number who
voted for Joe Biden. We should be trying to trying to encourage more people to
vote, not discourage them. But for Republicans, greater democracy is anathema
because like all masters of the plantation, they fear as much as they patronize
the plebes, which is why Republicans always seem to demonize those who promote
such “socialist” ideas like affordable health care; it makes them more “equal.”
Despite the Electoral College vote, the danger
is still not over. The refusal of Trump’s most fanatical supporters to accept
reality and possibly react “affirmatively” to Trump’s call to “action” cannot
be dismissed out of hand as a “hoax,” since Trump has taken pains not to
discourage such action. That is what a “leader” with authoritarian impulses
does with the help of far-right media propaganda that lends “deep state” conspiracies
a measure of “credence” for a “base” that craves authoritarian leaders who promise
to dispose of their social and ideological “enemies” and undesirables.
No comments:
Post a Comment