There
seems to be a number of definitions of what a “hero” is, often political. In Chris
Stuckman’s YouTube video essay “The Problem with Action Movies Today,” he notes
that in the film Lucy, once Scarlett
Johansson’s character “unlocked” her mind, there was “no one left alive to
challenge her,” and she left a predictable number of people dead without
blinking an eye, making her “action” scenes “tensionless.” How can you care
about a “hero” who is invulnerable, a mere killing machine? Why would you even
call someone like that a “hero”? The only people who can “identify” with such a
person are those who like to see a lot of people die, especially if they are
all males. Another problem is that for some people such juvenile revenge
fantasies are “real.” Back in the day if there were such invulnerable
characters, they were nearly always evil and a human “hero” was forced to use
some inventive way to destroy them. If there were “humans” who could wipeout
hoards of other humans, like Victor Mature’s Samson in the 1949 film, who
supposedly kills 10,000 Philistine soldiers with the jaw bone of an Ass, we
know that it is not the literal truth, but a symbol of the power of some higher
being.
But
more to the point, a real “hero” is someone who risks his or her own life to
save that of others. To her credit, Shults acknowledged that she had
help from her co-pilot, Darren Ellisor, and they both stated that they were not
“heroes,” but just doing their jobs. What can be said is that there was no
“pilot error” in this case, unlike that of the US Airways flight made famous by
the film Sully, in which “pilot
error” can be said to be the reason why that plane's engines were damaged was because the pilots flew the plane
through a flock of geese (much less excusable than a Horizon flight I saw that
was forced to return to SeaTac Airport with a Peregrine falcon splattered on
its cockpit window). We can also agree that not everyone can fly an airplane;
that takes special skill and training. Hoorah. But if we needed “heroes” to fly
them, then why would passengers ever feel “safe” during a flight? Some guy on
Inc.com was decrying the cynicism of people like me, but he still didn’t
explain why Shults was more “heroic” than Ellisor or heroic at all. Juliette
Kayyem of CNN praised her “nerves of steel,” not mentioning the co-pilot role;
I also take that former Homeland Security official’s opinion with another touch
of cynicism, because this is the same person who employed barely concealed
racial code in her book Security Mom.
But is such cynicism deserved?
Take two famous cases where white females received accolades for “heroic”
action that was out of all proportion to the facts. Perhaps the most infamous
example is that of Jessica Lynch, whose supply convoy in Iraq was ambushed and
11 soldiers killed in 2003. It was all over the media that Lynch had gone down
fighting before being captured, and was repeatedly raped by her captors before
being heroically rescued by American forces. She was later awarded a Bronze
Star, which apparently has a different standard than when it did in, say, the
Vietnam War. The truth, as Lynch herself confessed, was that she had been
knocked unconscious and remembered nothing before she found herself in an Iraqi
hospital. She had never fired her weapon, and she didn’t “remember” being
sexually assaulted.
Lynch also wasn’t the only
soldier captured (there were five others, just not attractive white females)
and one soldier, Lori Ann Piestewa (a Hopi Indian) was the first female soldier
to die in the Iraq War. She was almost completely ignored by the media engaged in its
Lynch propaganda machine. Lynch also received much more attention than
Marine Sergeant Fernando Padilla-Ramirez, who was killed in another ambush a
short time later, his body dragged through the streets of Ash Shatrah. His body
was later hung in the town square; some town residents disturbed by what
happened showed more respect for Padilla-Ramirez than the U.S. media, taking
his body down and giving him a proper burial.
Iraqi medical personnel did
everything they could for the badly wounded Lynch, and even begged the U.S.
military to take her off their hands. But U.S. officials were more interested
in using Lynch for propaganda purposes, and the U.S. media was all in. It is
interesting to note that U.S. forces did not attempt the rescue until after Iraqi security had left the area,
thus the “rescue” was little more than a cakewalk. The Guardian offered this story from the Iraqi perspective:
The doctors in Nassiriya say they provided the best treatment they
could for Lynch in the midst of war. She was assigned the only specialist bed
in the hospital, and one of only two nurses on the floor. "I was like a
mother to her and she was like a daughter,"says Khalida Shinah.
"We gave her three bottles of blood, two of them from the medical
staff because there was no blood at this time,"said Dr Harith al-Houssona,
who looked after her throughout her ordeal. "I examined her, I saw she had
a broken arm, a broken thigh and a dislocated ankle. Then I did another
examination. There was no [sign of] shooting, no bullet inside her body, no
stab wound - only RTA, road traffic accident," he recalled. "They
want to distort the picture. I don't know why they think there is some benefit
in saying she has a bullet injury."
"We heard the noise of helicopters," says Dr Anmar Uday. He
says that they must have known there would be no resistance. "We were
surprised. Why do this? There was no military, there were no soldiers in the
hospital.
"It was like a Hollywood film. They cried, 'Go, go, go', with guns
and blanks and the sound of explosions. They made a show - an action movie like
Sylvester Stallone or Jackie Chan, with jumping and shouting, breaking down
doors." All the time with the camera rolling. The Americans took no
chances, restraining doctors and a patient who was handcuffed to a bed frame.
There was one more twist. Two days before the snatch squad arrived,
Al-Houssona had arranged to deliver Jessica to the Americans in an ambulance.
"I told her I will try and help you escape to the American Army but I will
do this very secretly because I could lose my life." He put her in an
ambulance and instructed the driver to go to the American checkpoint. When he
was approaching it, the Americans opened fire. They fled just in time back to
the hospital. The Americans had almost killed their prize catch.
A military cameraman had shot footage of the rescue. It was a race
against time for the video to be edited. The video presentation was ready a few
hours after the first brief announcement. When it was shown, General Vincent
Brooks, the US spokesman in Doha, declared: "Some brave souls put their
lives on the line to make this happen, loyal to a creed that they know that
they'll never leave a fallen comrade."
Dr Jamal Kadhim Shwail was the first
doctor to examine Lynch when she was brought to Nassiriya's military hospital
by Iraqi special police.
Shwail said Lynch was lying in the
crowded reception of the hospital, unconscious and in shock from blood loss.
She was wearing her uniform including a
flak jacket, military trousers and boots, none of her clothes had been
unbuttoned or removed, as the book claims, he said.
"We only had a few minutes to save
her life, we found a vein in her neck to give her fluids and blood,"
Shwail told Reuters at his home in Nassiriya.
A team of five doctors treated Lynch,
who was given an anaesthetic to allow a 15-cm (six-inch) cut to her head to be
stitched and her fractures realigned.
No signs
He said her flak jacket was removed and
her clothes were cut away to expose the injured sites. The anaesthetist cut
away an area around her groin to insert a catheter to drain urine.
Lynch, now 20, was the same age as his
eldest daughter Noor, said Shwail. A copy of People magazine with the blonde
soldier's smiling face on the cover lay on the couch beside him.
"She was a woman, young and alone
in a strange country," he said. "It was our duty to look after her
and we did. Now people are saying she was raped... it pains us."
Shwail said he saw no signs of rape but
neither was he looking for them.
"The thought did not cross my
mind. Her injuries were consistent with severe trauma, a car crash, nothing
else. Her clothes were not torn, her boots had not been removed. There is no
way (she could have been raped)."
Shortly afterwards Lynch was
transferred to Saddam Hospital in Nassiriya, now renamed Nassiriya General.
Body was broken
There, Dr Mahdi Khafazji operated on
her fractured right femur when her condition had stabilised. He said he cleaned
her body before surgery and found no signs of a sexual assault.
"I examined her very
carefully," he said at his private clinic in the centre of Nassiriya.
"I cleaned her body including her genitalia. She had no sign of raping or
sodomising."
He said Lynch's injuries were so severe
she would have died had she been sexually assaulted after she was wounded.
"If she had been raped there is no
way she could have survived it. She was fighting for her life, her body was
broken. What sort of an animal would even think of that?"
During the days Lynch was in hospital,
Nassiriya was battered by fighting.
Hundreds of civilian casualties poured
into the hospital, but a senior medical team assigned to Lynch made sure she
had the best care the hospital could provide, and a female nurse was constantly
at her bedside, said Dr Khudair al-Hazbar, then deputy director of the Saddam
hospital.
"It was war, but we cared about
her and we did everything we could for her," he said. "I spoke to her
every day. She was frightened, but polite to us. I know she is grateful"
On 1 April, after Iraqi forces had
deserted the hospital, it was raided by US commandos. The event was filmed by
the US military through a night-vision lens and Lynch was stretchered away.
"They attacked the hospital at
night. There were explosions outside which broke the windows. The patients were
terrified," he said. "The Americans knew the Iraqi military had gone
so why they didn't come for her quietly, I don't know."
It
seems that Lynch was actually in the “right” place in more ways than one; it
also “helped” that she was an “attractive” blonde, blue-eyed white female. She
even received money for a book deal which was entirely pointless, save for
“clarifying” a few details that the media deliberately got wrong. Considering
the way the media ignored the presence of a wounded black female soldier (Shoshana
Johnson) who was also captured with Lynch, and the way the media later demonized
and dehumanized a “white” Hispanic, George Zimmerman, who clearly acted in
self-defense, the racial aspect cannot be ignored.
And then there was the case of the Fort Hood massacre perpetrated
by Nidal Malik Hassan in 2009, who, we were breathlessly told by both the
military and the media, was “felled” by a “heroic” military policewoman,
Kimberly Munley. Or was he? According to an Associated
Press story
One Fort Hood official described how a wounded Munley stayed on her
feet in a raging gun battle with Hasan and ended his rampage with two
well-placed bullets into his torso.
That account appears to be false.
Mark Todd, 42, said Thursday his bullets felled Hasan. Providing the most
detailed account of the takedown, Todd said he and Munley arrived at the base
processing center at the same time, but split up.
Munley encountered Hasan first and was shot three times in the ensuing
gun battle. It's unclear if Hasan was hit.
Still on his feet, the blood-thirsty Army psychiatrist paused to load
his handgun before Todd found him.
"I came around. I challenged him. I saw him turn toward me and I
started taking fire again, and then I returned fire," Todd told NBC’s
"Today" show.
Todd said that his shots knocked Hasan off of his feet and he then he
checked the gunman for other weapons.
"I thank God to this day that I wasn't hit," Todd added.
"It was a miracle."
Note the term "blood-thirsty" being used as an "explanation" for Munley's failure. Although Munley exchanged fire
with Hassan, she failed to hit him and was herself incapacitated by those three
shots; Hassan apparently chose not to kill her, merely kicking her weapon away
from where she lay. It was the civilian policeman, Todd (who is black), who
eventually confronted Hassan and felled him after firing five shots. The
interesting thing was that for a long time Todd’s role in the incident was a
“mystery” to the media; Munley—who is of course white and “attractive”—was
feted by the media, yet her role in the incident was in fact ineffectual. When
the truth finally did surface, I recall how CNN anchor Wolf Blitzer displayed
barely-disguised disgust that Todd would try to muscle-in on Munley’s “glory,”
demeaning his own role.
Cynicism? Why not? I don’t think
I’m being “sexist” here, either; women are no more or less human than men are.
I think it is those who are “impressed” that a woman can act “calmly” and
competently while doing the job they have been trained to do are the ones who are
“sexist,” all things under consideration; it doesn’t “help” women’s credibility
by lying about things they clearly did not do.